Bad Theology: A Special Edition for St. Patrick’s Day

wp_20170104_14_18_20_proFor a brief look into St. Patrick’s history, with a healthy dose of good Theology thrown in, please turn to Mitch Teemley’s post: Forgiveness + Love = Freedom.

It brought to mind a book I read… couldn’t remember the name, but I knew it had something to do with Celtic Christianity. So that’s what I Googled.

Little did I know it would lead me down a rabbit hole toward Bad Theology…

Not that I think Celtic Christianity is bad, but the first website that popped up sure did. Here’s a quote from an article this guy wrote entitled “Celtic Christianity is not Authentic Christianity”:

Celtics say that,
“God always seeks us out, working for our healing and restoration”.
This is not true. He has predestinated some to be elect. The rest are doomed to hell and will never, ever, be saved or go to Heaven. The statement by Celtics is what we hear from modern churchgoers who have little or no discernment. The idea that God is forever seeking out people is wrong: God already knows who will be saved, so He does not need to find them!

Wow… um… way to sell it there, pal.

I read the full article, plus the comments. Here’s a bit of the comments (Brid is speaking against the article, K B Napier is the author, Fr. Sean Connery – for real! – is third):

Screen Shot 2017-03-16 at 1.26.31 PM

Full disclosure: I’d consider converting to Catholicism if my priest was Sean Connery.

I realize the comments are in tiny print, just know that Brid and Sean are saying the guy is WRONG, WRONG, WRONG, and the guy is saying NUH-UH!

Later in the comments, when someone suggests he stop mudslinging other Christians, abusing Catholics, and being so, you know, judgmental, he states:

ALL denominations are unbalanced.
As for Catholicism – I take it your comment was a joke. Catholicism is not even Christian, let alone authentic.
There can be no commonality.
Only God’s word is truth.
The rest are to be cast aside as evil.
Thus, all false religions are our enemies.
It is tiresome to read your last statement, because we are commanded to judge… the only time we may not judge is when we are ourselves guilty of the same accusations. Read the Bible!


Now here’s the thing: as those of us who have blogs can tell you, any Jack can have a blog. And any Jack with a blog can have an opinion, and usually does. Otherwise, what’s the point of having a blog?

So here’s my opinion, Jack… er, K B Napier:

For preaching that God does not seek and love all people, for casting aside as “evil” all Christian denominations, for your blind hatred of Catholics (and disrespecting Fr. Sean Connery),  and for tarnishing the good name of St. Patrick and his day (no doubt being against green beer too), you’ve earned:

Three Facepalms and Two Get-Thee-Behind-Me-Satans!

Until next week,
Vaya con Dios

P.S. The book I couldn’t think of earlier was The Celtic Way of Evangelism, by George Hunter III. Another good book is How the Irish Saved Civilization, by Thomas Cahill. Both use well-researched, historically accurate information. K B Napier would hate them. 😉

10 thoughts on “Bad Theology: A Special Edition for St. Patrick’s Day

    1. It didn’t occur to me until just now that my title might have caused concern when you got the pingback! Sorry if that’s the case. In all honesty, I’ve never once done a facepalm with any your posts. 😉
      I’m sometimes fond of Calvinists — in fact I married one — though American Presbyterians are a different breed when all is said and done. 😊

  1. My favorite book on Celtic Christianity is: “Listening for the Heartbeat of God: A Celtic Spirituality” by J Philip Newell. I attended a Presbyterian church for awhile. I was elected an Elder. Then I decided I shouldn’t belong to a church that thought I was good material to be an Elder and moved back to the Methodists and their quest for the perfect potluck dish.

    1. Haha! The thing about being a Presbyterian elder is that they ordain you FOR LIFE! There’s no escaping it, Andrew. You’re stuck. 😉
      Thanks for the tip on the book, sounds like a good one!

    1. You would have been amazed at his site. He wrote on just about every topic you can imagine, and was pretty much against everything. You gotta figure, he must be a terribly unhappy guy. We should probably pity him, I suppose. I’ll get to work on that… later. After I’m through poking pins in the voodoo doll I made of him. 😉

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s